The Pizza Peel

Reviews

• Billy M.

  star star star star star_border 11 June 2026

  Has some of the best pizza! I've been to the one in matthews. The service was great and the menu has so much to choose from. I would order The Godfather pizza

• Josh V.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 6 June 2026

  Ever walked into a restaurant and be looked upon by staff as if you were a cockroach except they just leered at you instead of squishing you with their foot. That's what happened tonight. We seated ourselves and sat at the table unattended for ten minutes while he casually cleaned tables and watched the game.  He didn't even bother to make eye contact let alone give us a menu.   I usually love pizza peal, but ownership should be aware they have some bad eggs working this shift.

• Kate T.

  star star star star_border star_border 6 June 2026

  After years of having Pizza Peel bookmarked I finally had the opportunity to check them out.
  Although they are somewhat hidden, off a side street, they definitely seem to have their regulars.
  
  I arrived on a weeknight and decided to sit at the bar. I ordered a drink, wasn't too impressed, so switched to a beer.
  After checking out the menu, which offers a lot more than pizzas, I decided to stick with pizza being my first visit.
  Yes, it was good, but nothing out of the ordinary.
  I definitely want would love to go back and check out some of their other menu options.

• A S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 23 May 2026

  Not sure how this place can call them self's a pizza place. This is the third time I have received burnt pizza. I will never go back. It is so sad, as this was the only place I would get pizza from. I would rather order Dominio's pizza over this place. At least the order is right and they are beyond fair with topping too, also they do not burn their pizzas. It is a shame they have new management because it is clearly not working for them. Definitely save your money and go elsewhere as this place could care less about making pizzas the right way. By the way, we ordered two large pizzas both of them were burnt and cost $45.00.  Again save your money.

• Kayla M.

  star star star star star_border 21 May 2026

  Pizza. Social. Convenient. Local.
  Go for the pizza. Either build your own or get one of their signature pies. The apps are fairly standard - wings, dips, garlic knots - what more do you need when you have a pizza in the oven?!
  
  We got pasta and the Mediterranean app last week and were moderately pleased. After we scarfed down our eggplant parmesan (no cheese for me) out of pure starvation, we both commented on the meal and wished we had gone with the pizza. Bea cause we know it is GOOD.
  
  Go for the pizza. Stay for the cozy welcoming atmosphere and the draft list. The Cotswold location is tucked away and often not as busy as the Central location!